Every Thanksgiving since I can remember, we’ve cooked and served the same dishes: turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, Great-Grandma’s cranberry salad, Dad’s homemade whole wheat rolls, green bean casserole, and sweet potatoes. (Don’t forget the pumpkin and pecan pies, complete with whipped cream, for after the feast!)
Sometime during middle school, we nixed the green bean casserole in favorite of lightly steaming the veggies instead. Then a few holidays later, in my last year of high school or first semester at college, Mom decided to try a new sweet potato dish.
Our original recipe was about as traditional as they come: sliced sweet potatoes combined with green apples, baked with cinnamon and brown sugar, then topped with toasted marshmallows. If my family felt a little crazy, they even added pecans to half. (My brother and I hated nuts back then!)
But that particular November, Mom tentatively approached me the night before while holding out an issue of Cooking Light, my favorite magazine. She pointed at a recipe for mashed sweet potato casserole, explaining that she was thinking about making it, but she wanted to ask Dad and me first. Up until then, we both loved our traditional Thanksgiving menu!
After skimming through the recipe, I agreed to give it a try, and when I took my first bite the following afternoon at our feast, I nearly replaced my entire plate with the casserole dish! Those creamy sweet potatoes, with hint of cinnamon and sweet maple syrup, practically tasted like pumpkin pie.
This year, I decided to come up with my own slightly healthier version and created this Maple Sweet Potato Casserole. It has all of the same cozy and addictive flavors but none of the refined sugar. Thank goodness my guy hates sweet potatoes… I didn’t want to share a single bite!
To speed up the process, I baked my sweet potatoes in the microwave for just 8-10 minutes on high, turning them oven halfway through. It’s so much faster than waiting an hour for them to finish in the oven! Then I scooped out the insides but left a little clinging to the skin…
Because I have an incredible recipe for sweet potato skins I’m posting in a few days that are perfect for leftovers! So I highly recommend that you do the same. Just pop those in a plastic bag and refrigerate until you’re ready to make the stuffed skins.
Now beat the insides with an electric mixer and add the rest of the ingredients. The egg white helps give them structure and hold them together after baking, while the butter and milk provide richness and the maple syrup boosts their naturally sweet flavor.
To finish off the casserole, I didn’t want to use the traditional marshmallows, and from the sounds of the comments some of you posted on Facebook, you prefer your casserole without. Instead, I made my favorite maple glaze with Greek yogurt and maple syrup to drizzle over the top. It’s the perfect creamy compliment to the cinnamon-spiced sweet potatoes!
The first day I made this cozy Maple Sweet Potato Casserole, I immediately inhaled two servings for lunch. Followed by another as a snack. And a fourth as dessert. Yes, I ate vegetables for dessert instead of cookies or cupcakes—they’re that addictive!
We may need a double batch for Thanksgiving… One for me and one for everyone else!
This creamy casserole practically tastes like pumpkin pie! It tastes lovely served warm or cold, making it the perfect make-ahead healthy holiday side dish. Store any leftovers in the refrigerator in an airtight container for up to 3 days.
- Preheat the oven to 350°F, and lightly coat an 8”-square pan with nonstick cooking spray.
- Liberally pierce the sweet potatoes with a fork. Place on a microwave-safe plate, and microwave on HIGH for 4-5 minutes. Turn the sweet potatoes upside down, and microwave for an additional 4-5 minutes, or until fork tender. Let them rest for 5 minutes before slicing open and scooping out the insides, leaving a ¼” layer still clinging to the skin. Set aside the skins for stuffed sweet potato skins (recipe coming soon!), and place in an airtight container in the refrigerator once cool.
- Add the sweet potato insides and remaining casserole ingredients to a medium bowl, and beat with an electric mixer until creamy. Spread into the bottom of the prepared pan, and bake at 350°F for 20-24 minutes. Cool for at least 10 minutes before serving.
- Just before serving, prepare the drizzle by stirring together the yogurt and maple syrup in a small bowl. Spoon into a zip-topped plastic bag, snip off one corner, and drizzle over the sweet potatoes.
Notes: After scraping from the skins, the total amount of sweet potato insides should be about 500 grams, or just over 1 pound. If you prefer to peel off the skin instead of saving it to make stuffed sweet potato skins, you’ll only need about 3 medium-large sweet potatoes instead.
{gluten-free, clean eating, low fat, low calorie}
Always love finding a new recipe for sweet potatoes since I love them so much! I like the maple syrup drizzle on top too, sounds great.
Thanks Kaylin! I love them too, but it’s a shame my guy doesn’t. He’d rather have regular potatoes… Oh well, more for me and you! 😉
I love how the Thanksgiving menu can evolve over the years! I’ve never been a fan of the classic pureed sweet potatoes with brown sugar on top. Is it weird that I will only eat my sweet potatoes savory? Pinning and stumbling!
You’re so sweet Lee! Thanks for the pin and stumble! 🙂 Totally not weird at all. I love sweet potatoes with a little cheese and rosemary too!
amy, this looks like the perfect Thanksgiving side dish!
Thank you so much Heather!
OMG Amy, I love love love this. I’m definitely making!! And I don’t plan to wait until Thanksgiving to make this 🙂
Thank you so much Susan! I’d love to hear what you think of the casserole. I couldn’t wait for Thanksgiving either; it’s one of my favorite dishes of fall!
Just wanted to say that I made this recipe for last years Thanksgiving & Christmas dinners. Since it was such a big success last year, I’m making it this year for Thanksgiving!! It’s incredible and everyone raves about it. Thank you for such an amazing recipe 🙂
I’m touched Brianna! That’s so sweet of you to include one of my recipes as a new holiday tradition. I hope you and your loved ones enjoy the casserole as much this year as you did last year! 🙂
just clicked here from protein overnight oats recipe, wish I’d found it sooner, I;m always looking for new sweet potato recipes and this looks wonderful, thank you for sharing this!
It’s my pleasure Sabrina! I’d love to hear what you think of either recipe if you try them! 🙂
thank you so much I wanted to have this dish for my supper with baked fish so I will ..
I can’t wait to hear what you think of this sweet potato casserole Dottie! 🙂
Hi Well I made the pumpkin casserole last night. It was the star of my meal. I really enjoyed the taste & texture of the dish, I had Haddock filet with olive oil & lemon juice ,baked, small salad, and a square of this great casserole. After 2 hours I took my Blood sugar
and it was 117. When I went to bed I still was comfortable full. Usually I get hunger pains during the night but woke up still not hungry. I Just know it was the sweet potatoes. Thanks Dottie
WOW! I’m so happy to hear that Dottie! That truly means a lot to me. I’m really glad you loved the casserole, and I’m so honored that you’d call it the star of your meal! 🙂