Last Sunday, afternoon a long day at the dealership, my guy drove home in a brand new car! He arrived just before dinner, so we spent a few minutes strolling around it on the driveway before sitting down to eat. Once we finished, he went back outside to play around with a few of the fun features—including calling me from the Bluetooth in the dashboard.
Once he got the hang of dialing and syncing the songs on his iPhone to the stereo, I hopped into the passenger’s seat for a short ride around my hometown. He excitedly navigated around the empty streets while I pointed out places from my childhood.
There’s my middle school, with the gym that looks like Alcatraz…
There’s the 7-11, where we begged Mom for afternoon slurpees…
There’s the grocery store with the bakery that handed out a free cookie to any kid who stopped by…
There’s the best donut shop in town, with too many options to choose from…
But in my sleepy state, the memories started blending together. Cookies… Donuts… Cookies… Donuts… They must have infiltrated my dreams because I woke up the next morning with the thought, “Cookie donut holes!”
So that’s exactly what I made!
Less than an hour later, a plate of these Baked Snickerdoodle Donut Holes sat on the counter in all their sweet cinnamony glory, tempting me, my parents, and even the construction crew… We didn’t stand a chance. The entire batch disappeared in less than 10 minutes!
Although I’ll never deny a regular friend donut, especially one of the kiddie chocolate ones with chocolate glaze and rainbow sprinkles (or a cinnamon crumb, or an old-fashioned, or… well, okay, all of them!), I can’t quite run enough miles to make up for devouring a dozen. So when I make my own at home, I bake them instead—which totally means I can eat more. Right?
To do that, I bought an inexpensive cake pop maker. Its cavities are the perfect shape and size for donut holes! I can tuck it into the pantry (or, umm, the spare bedroom… our kitchen is the size of a coat closet!) when I’m not using it, and I love how it doesn’t require turning on the oven and heating up the house. If you’d rather not buy a new gadget, a regular cake pop pan works just fine—or even a mini muffin pan!
To create the characteristic snickerdoodle cookie flavor, you need 3 key ingredients.
Butter. Okay, I know this might sound obvious, but… I tried making donut holes without it, and they tasted like pancakes (according to my guy). Just a tiny bit of melted butter mixed into the batter makes the donut holes incredibly soft and tender—and really helps with the buttery snickerdoodle flavor too!
Butter extract. Just an itty bitty amount! A mere ¼ teaspoon adds a buttery cookie flavor to the donut holes, something that plain vanilla extract just can’t quite achieve. You can generally find it on the baking aisle next to the other extracts, or if you live near Walmart, check their wedding aisle. They sell a big 4-ounce bottle for just $4! It’s shelf-stable and keeps for ages, and you can make this and these with the rest!
Cinnamon sugar. No need to buy any—just mix regular granulated sugar with a little cinnamon! Snickerdoodle dough is typically rolled in cinnamon sugar right before baking, and the cookies develop an irresistible sweet crust. We’re going to do that to these donuts holes too by coating them with it after they bake!
Now don’t tell anyone this, but… These donut holes taste almost as addictive even without the cinnamon sugar. I couldn’t stop nibbling on the freshly baked ones as I waited for the second round to finish!
After my dad’s first bite of these Baked Snickerdoodle Donut Holes, he turned to me and stated, “These are going to be one of the best things you ever post on your blog!” With their rich buttery flavor and sweet explosion of cinnamon sugar… I certainly hope he’s right!
Because who wouldn’t want cookies for breakfast?