Send Me Free Recipes!

Comments

  1. Hi Amy, this is a good recipe but I had to go through 29 ads before I got to the end of the recipe! So I’m not sure if I will continue to receive your recipes because of this. Thank you, Yvette

    • I’m honored by your kind words about my recipe, Yvette! I completely understand. Your time is valuable, and you deserve to spend it in ways that you see fit. No hard feelings whatsoever should you decide to unsubscribe from my recipe email updates! 🙂 Amy’s Healthy Baking is my full-time job, and the ads are what allow me to keep my recipes free to anyone to view. Without them, I’d have to completely shut down my blog, and I’d much rather continue to create recipes for anyone to try!

      Should you change your mind and decide to try making these cookies, I’d love to hear what you think of them!

  2. Hi Amy! Thank you so much for your recipes. They are honestly edible miracles. Can you substitute erythritol for coconut sugar/ granulated sugar in your cookie recipes? You have so many Christmas cookie recipes that call for coconut sugar, but all I have is Swerve, Truvia and sweetleaf stevia packets. Happy Holidays!
    Shelby5 stars

    • You’re just the sweetest, Shelby! “Edible miracles” — you just made my entire day!! ♡

      It actually depends! For my drop-style cookie recipes (like these!), you can typically substitute erythritol for coconut sugar, brown sugar, or granulated sugar. However, because it absorbs and dissolves differently in liquids compared to these other three sugars, you’ll need to add about 2 ½ – 3 tablespoons of milk (any type will work!) to get the same cookie dough consistency. Sometimes cookies made with erythritol as a substitute spread a little less too — just something to keep in mind! 🙂

      I’d love to hear what you think of these chocolate hazelnut cookies if you decide to try making them — or any of my other cookie recipes too!

    • I really appreciate your interest in my recipe, Sarah! I typically don’t recommend that substitution. This is because you want a fat source that will completely turn into a liquid when heated (aka when you put the cookie dough in the oven!) for the best taste and texture. Although it turns thinner when heated, peanut butter doesn’t completely turn into a liquid the same way that vegan butter and coconut oil do, so it’ll change the texture of these cookies (they’d be more cakey and less chewy). However, if you don’t mind that texture difference, then you can try that substitution. You may need to add a bit more milk to the cookie dough because peanut butter is thicker than melted vegan butter and coconut oil, so you may not be able to incorporate quite all of the cocoa powder mixture without a little extra milk.

      Does all of that make sense? 🙂

      If you decide to try making these cookies, I’d love to hear what you think of them!

  3. This recipe looks so delicious that it will disappear as soon as I make it. Thanks for posting this delicious recipe!

  4. Are these cookies supposed to be baked at 350°F or 325°F? Step 1 says to preheat to 350°F, but step 3 says to bake at 325°F. I baked at 350°F for 9 minutes and they seem to have come out well. I used brown Swerve instead of coconut sugar and had to add 2 tbs of warm almond milk. I am not sure if that is only because of the sugar replacement or if there was a measurement wrong in the recipe. The dough was definitely not sticky, but actually quite crumbly. They smell and taste quite good, though. They are probably the best cookies I have made from any of your recipes. Thanks.4 stars

    • Thank you so much for catching that typo, Lauren! All fixed. 🙂

      The dough texture was actually due to your substitution! Swerve is erythritol-based, and although it basically sweetens cup-for-cup like coconut sugar and brown sugar, it doesn’t actually behave quite like them. It both absorbs and dissolves in liquids differently, so when substituting it for coconut sugar in my cookie recipes, you’ll need to add an additional 5 tablespoons of milk per cup of Swerve to get the same cookie dough consistency, amount of spread while baking, and chewy texture in your fully baked cookies.

      I’m so glad you loved these cookies, and it means the world that you’d call them the best of any that you’ve made from my recipes! Thank you so much for taking the time to share that little detail with me! ♡

  5. Hi Amy! I want to express how much your website helped me during the past few months! In March, I came across your healthy carrot cake oatmeal cookies recipe and fell in love! Since then, I’ve bookmarked more than 50 of your recipes and tried at least 20 of them! They always have good results~ I even made your simple lemon strawberry cake for a friend’s birthday! Anyways.. sorry for the long comment, but thank you for motivating me so much that I decided to start blogging too!! My website is bitesofbetter.com It would be unbelievable if you see my blog someday (literally I see you as a celebrity! I follow all your social media)~ I would be so happy even if you just read this comment 🙂 PS. I love chemistry and science too!!5 stars

    • Oh my goodness, Stella… Your comment just made my entire MONTH!! My heart feels so happy and full right now. That means the world to me that you’ve bookmarked and tried so many of my recipes! I’m truly honored that you’d make my cake recipe for your friend’s birthday to celebrate such a special occasion. You’re such a sweetheart and a true gem! ♡♡♡

      • Amy, I’m so glad that I made you feel happy!!! It’s weird how I’ve been reading your blog for so long and I know you often reply to comments, but I didn’t build up the nerves to leave a comment until just a few days ago. I really appreciate your dedicated and long reply 💖 I know that you haven’t been posting as much recently and I hope you are doing well 🙂 Your posts are always so sweet and your stories are great!

        • Aww, you’re going to make my entire day all over again!! You’re just the sweetest, Stella! ♡ It means SO much to me that you read all of my blog posts, including the stories, and it means even more that you’d find the courage to leave me a comment and take the time to let me know. I’m so grateful for you!

          Sending you so much love and a big virtual hug!

    • I’m so glad you and your family loved these biscotti, Jason! Thanks for taking the time to let me know! 🙂

    • I really appreciate your interest in my recipe, Ruby! I’m not quite sure what you mean. Would you like to chop up the protein bar and mix it into the cookie dough? Or did you have something else in mind?

4.77 from 13 votes

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating